A friend of mine mentioned reciting the Pledge of Allegiance at her school yesterday; every time I hear a modern reference to it my first thought is, "Wow, we still
do that?" The pledge is, or
should be, a relic. It belongs to another, past world: a world of nuclear families and nuclear bomb shelters, a world where
censors object to the flushing of a toilet.
When I think of the pledge, I do not think of loyalty or patriotism; instead I think of 'Under God', and
only 'Under God'. Growing up as an atheist child, I must have recited the pledge hundreds of times. Sometimes I wouldn't say The Words and sometimes I think I would. Whether or not I said them I felt bitter and hypocritical and confused and tainted. Without The Words I probably would've viewed the pledge as mostly harmless -- maybe a little indoctrinal but mainly just a nice attempt to encourage patriotism -- but
with the words the entire pledge was bullshit. A bullshit instrument of orthodoxy. We don't live under 'God', I thought; at least, I don't, and neither do lots of us -- not just atheists but Hindus and Buddhists and Deists and whatnot -- so either we're not American (which we clearly are) or this pledge is bullshit (which it ipso facto was). I felt like I was being forced to make a choice: either be American and Christian, or be neither, or lie about it.
It was one thing to me to be forced to express loyalty to my country; that was not ideal, but it was fine, it was only politics. But to enfold God into the pledge seems like a sneaky way of getting people to profess their loyalty to Him, which struck me as a big transgression. God (or absence thereof) REALLY MATTERED and should be above such petty trickery.
Historically, as we all know, the words were inserted in the 50's when many people were obsessed with Communism, in the same way many people are obsessed now by birth certificates and death panels. Granted, there was a great deal to fear about the
USSR, but what good is achieved by inserting the words besides grandstanding and assholery?
Ultimately of course it's only words and it seems like we stopped saying it sometime in elementary school, and in the grand scheme of Oppression it's small potatoes; but at the time it was clear, unmistakable evidence that not all authority figures were worthy of respect. That our leaders and our elected representatives were just as capable of manipulation and coercion as a bunch of second graders.